What they did not teach you. What the files confirm.

Why Did the Catholic Church Ban Freemasonry? The 1738 Bull Explained

Why did the Catholic Church ban Freemasonry? Pope Clement XII issued the bull In eminenti apostolatus in April 1738, the first papal prohibition of Masonic associations, on the grounds that lodges bound members by oaths of secrecy, mixed people of every religion under a vague natural virtue, and were already being suppressed by governments as dangerous. Politics, not only doctrine, shaped the timing. The Church has restated the ban repeatedly, most recently in a Vatican note of 13 November 2023.

Verdict: ● Documented (the ban and its history) · ◐ Disputed (how much was politics versus doctrine) · ✕ Not supported (that the bull accused Masons of Satanism or of ruling the world)

Key facts at a glance

Question Short answer
What is In eminenti apostolatus? A papal bull by Clement XII, the first canonical ban on Masonic associations
Date Dated 24 April 1738 and issued on 28 April 1738 (sources differ)
Penalty in 1738 Excommunication
Restated by Benedict XIV (1751), Pius VII (1821), Leo XII (1825), Leo XIII (Humanum genus, 1884) and others
Law since 1983 Canon 1374 does not name Masons; excommunication is no longer automatic
Latest Vatican statement Note of 13 November 2023, published 15 November

The claims, weighed

Claim Verdict What the record says
The Church has banned Freemasonry since 1738 ● Documented In eminenti apostolatus, Clement XII, 1738
The ban was purely religious ◐ Disputed Rivalry between Jacobites and Hanoverians and government bans in France and elsewhere played a part
Catholic Masons are excommunicated automatically today ✕ Not accurate The 1917 code (canon 2335) did so; the 1983 code made the penalty optional
The Church changed its mind in 1983 ✕ Not supported The 1983 Vatican declaration says the negative judgment is unchanged
The bull says Masons worship Satan ✕ Not supported Its stated reasons are secrecy, oaths, religious mixing and civil danger
The 2023 note is a new ban ✕ Not accurate It restates the existing prohibition in answer to a Philippine bishop

What was happening before 1738?

In 1736 the Inquisition investigated a lodge in Florence and condemned it in June 1737. In France, the chief minister Cardinal Fleury branded Freemasons traitors and banned their assemblies. A Jacobite-Hanoverian rivalry also played in the background: the exiled Stuart pretender asked for a condemnation of Hanoverian Freemasonry in Catholic Europe, while Clement XII wished neither to offend Britain nor to oppose France’s policy. Other authorities acted before and after Rome, among them Avignon, Paris and Geneva, Bern in 1745 and the Ottoman sultan in 1748.

What does In eminenti apostolatus say?

The bull says members “content with a form of natural virtue” bind themselves together with oaths and severe penalties to keep silent about their doings. It adds that several governments had suppressed such societies as harmful to the welfare of the kingdom, and that they are consistent with neither civil nor canon law and harm both the peace of the state and the salvation of souls. Catholics who joined or supported the lodges faced excommunication. Clement XII made no distinction between English and continental Freemasonry.

Which popes repeated the ban?

Benedict XIV renewed it in 1751 with Providas Romanorum, after the kings of Spain and Naples pressed him for church backing against Freemasonry. Pius VII (Ecclesiam a Jesu Christo, 1821) and Leo XII (Quo graviora, 1825) followed. Leo XIII’s encyclical Humanum genus of 20 April 1884 is the fullest statement. After the 1983 Code, the Vatican said the Church’s negative judgment on Masonic associations remains unchanged because their principles have always been considered irreconcilable with Catholic doctrine.

Is excommunication still automatic?

No. From 1738 until 1983 Catholics who publicly joined or supported Masonic organisations were subject to automatic excommunication, spelled out in canon 2335 of the 1917 code. The 1983 code dropped the explicit mention of Masons: canon 1374 provides a just penalty for joining an association that plots against the Church. The Vatican’s declaration of 26 November 1983 said the omission was an editorial choice, and that Catholics enrolled in Masonic associations are in a state of grave sin and may not receive Holy Communion.

What did the Vatican say in 2023?

On 13 November 2023 the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, with Pope Francis’s approval, answered Bishop Julito Cortes of Dumaguete, who was worried about growing Catholic enrolment in Philippine lodges. The note, published on 15 November, repeats that active membership in Freemasonry is forbidden because of its irreconcilability with Catholic doctrine, and asks the Philippine bishops for a coordinated strategy with catechesis in all parishes. It names religious indifferentism and a deistic idea of a “Great Architect” among the incompatible ideas.

How do Freemasons answer?

Masonic writers say the craft is not a religion or an enemy of any church. Lodges in the United Grand Lodge of England tradition require belief in a Supreme Being. The disagreement is real: the Church objects to the principle of a fraternity with its own ritual and a tolerance that treats religions as equivalent.

How to read the sources

Popular accounts on both sides can be partisan. We lean on the texts themselves, on the Holy See’s later statements and on historians’ accounts, and we note where sources differ, for example on the date of the bull.

FAQ

Why did the Catholic Church ban Freemasonry? Because of the secrecy and oaths of the lodges, their mixing of different religions, and political fears that governments shared.

When was Freemasonry banned by the Church? In 1738, by Clement XII’s bull In eminenti apostolatus.

Can a Catholic be a Freemason today? The Church says no. The Vatican restated this in 1983 and again on 13 November 2023.

Are Catholic Freemasons automatically excommunicated? Not since the 1983 Code of Canon Law, although the Church still says they are in grave sin and may not receive communion.

Did the Pope say Freemasons worship the devil? The 1738 bull does not say that.

Sources

The bull and its background

Later popes and canon law

The 2023 Vatican note

Books and further reading

  • José A. Ferrer Benimeli, Masonería, Iglesia e Ilustración, 4 vols., Fundación Universitaria Española, Madrid (1st ed. 1976; 2nd ed. 1983), cited in this article (Dialnet)
  • José A. Ferrer Benimeli, La Masonería, Alianza Editorial, Madrid 2019, 386 pp. (ISBN 978-84-9181-746-8), review

Written by The Archivist. Last updated 20 November 2026. Drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by a human. Sources are listed so you can check every claim.